Fleischer's Auctions
Live Auction

Fall Premier Sale, Day 2: Historic & Early Americana

Fri, Dec 11, 2026 09:00AM EST
  2026-12-11 09:00:00 2026-12-11 09:00:00 America/New_York Fleischer's Auctions Fleischer's Auctions : Fall Premier Sale, Day 2: Historic & Early Americana https://bid.fleischersauctions.com/auctions/fleischers-auctions/fall-premier-sale-day-2-historic-early-americana-22116
Fleischer’s Auctions’ Fall Premier Sale, featuring early and historically significant material relating to American history.
Fleischer's Auctions info@fleischersauctions.com
Lot 3085

[GOLD RUSH] 1849 California Pioneer Judge August M. Heslep & Family, Only Known Portrait

Estimate: $750 - $1,500
Starting Bid
$250

Bid Increments

Price Bid Increment
$0 $10
$100 $25
$300 $50
$1,000 $100
$2,000 $250
$5,000 $500
$10,000 $1,000
$50,000 $5,000

ONLY KNOWN PORTRAIT OF AUGUSTUS HESLEP, NOTORIOUS GOLD RUSH LAWYER

 

An important collection of seven 19th-century photographic portraits showing the family of prominent 1849 California Gold Rush pioneer, diarist, and jurist Judge August M. Heslep (ca. 1812–1886). Views listed below. 

 

Provenance: The collection appears to have descended through Clifford Lincoln Elliott (1897-1971), the grandson of Cassandra Heslep (1835-1916), the daughter of Augustus Heslep. Each of the cased images bears inscribed labels.

 

Dr. August M. Heslep was an influential, meticulously documented figure in the overland migration of the California Gold Rush. The second child of Thomas and Casandra Heslep of Pittsburgh, the family moved west to Illinois early in his youth. A curious and intellectual man, he became a physician and established a practice in St. Louis. In 1849, he sought to move to California with four of his brothers. Despite joining the fabled '49ers, his motivations, however, were to seek health restoration rather than gold. 

 

In May 1849, he departed St. Louis on the Timour and joined Morgan County and California Rangers of Illinois in Independence. They departed on May 15th, led by Captain Joseph Heslep, experienced Indian fighter James Kirker, and Augustus himself serving as physician. Travelling along the Santa Fe Trail, the party encountered buffalo herds, met many Indian tribes, and witnessed a standoff with over 160 Indians near Mann's Fort that ended peacefully with a council and "pipe of peace." Heslep maintained a detailed account of his overland journey, which was published by the Daily Missouri Republican. These letters remain a foundational primary source for Western migration historians (c.f. Bieber). 

 

After arriving in California, he earned the sobriquet "Hellslip" for his vindictive temperament and lawsuits. He helped prosecute Ned McGowan, survived a bullet in the back from Stockton founder Charles Weber (whom he then sued), and unwillingly became father-in-law to Sheriff Harry Morse, who eloped with his daughter, Virginia.

 

In 1855, his brother Joseph was murdered in a gold robbery by a man Heslep had personally vouched for. The killer confessed and was lynched by a mob. The next year Heslep joined San Francisco's Committee of Vigilance but was expelled after public accusations from his wife & daughter, Cassandra. He died alone in his law office in 1885, a Gold Rush firebrand who, per his own obituary, "created for himself few friends," though still described as "one of the patriarchs of Sacramento." 

 

A rare and important Gold Rush portrait archive. 

 

The lot includes:

 

1. Judge August M. Heslep, 1849 California Pioneer: Profile bust portrait. Sixth plate daguerreotype. Full leatherette case. Retains an early manuscript ink identification label affixed to the silk pad: "JUDGE A. M. HESLEP / GREAT, GREAT GRAND- / FATHER OF CLIFFORD / L. ELLIOTT".

 

Resolute three-quarters bust portrait of Heslep displaying high collar, black stock, and dark tailored coat.

 

2. Philander Heslep (1840-1912), Augustus' son. Seated half-length portrait. Sixth plate ambrotype. Half leatherette case. Outer case bears an early pasted paper label: "PHILANDER HESLIP / GREAT UNCLE TO / C. L. ELLIOTT".

 

Augustus's son and business partner with Harry Morse, the youthful Philander is captured wearing an open vest, broad collar, and oversized patterned bow tie. 

 

3. Cassandra Heslep Elliott, Augustus' daughter. Seated half-length portrait. Sixth plate ambrotype. Half leatherette case. Outer case bears an early pasted label: "MRS. C. H. ELLIOTT / GRANDMOTHER TO / C.L. ELLIOTT".

 

Cassandra Heslep Elliott (1835-1916), Heslep's second daughter, is seated wearing a dark silk bodice dress with gathered sleeves, delicate white lace collar, and hand-tinted gilt jewelry accents to her necklace and bodice buttons. She co-signed her mother's 1856 letter to the editor stating: "I have suffered much myself from his temper. He has spoken falsely of all of us."

 

4. Portrait of a Heslep Family member. Sixth plate tintype. Uncased.

 

Exceptional portrait of a mature gentleman with full thick beard and mustache, wearing a high-buttoned frock coat with a folded handkerchief in his breast pocket, likely dating from his later California years.

 

5. Group of three (3) portraits. Tintypes. Uncased. Featuring a seated young woman in Victorian dress, a man wearing a vest posed with arms akimbo, and a bust portrait of a mature gentleman with a full mustache and string bowtie.

 

References

"The Santa Fe Trail. Journals and Letters of Augustus M. Heslep." Ralph P. Bieber, ed. Southern Trails to California in 1849. Vol. 5. Southwest Historical Series. Glendale, California: The Arthur H. Clark Company, 1937. Pages 353-386. 

 

[California Gold Rush, 1849, Forty-Niner, Overland Trail, Judge August M. Heslep, Philander Heslep, Western Americana, San Joaquin County, Daguerreotype, Tintype, Cased Image, 19th Century Photography, Pioneer Archive, Pioneer Physician]

Very good to good condition overall. The Heslep daguerreotype displays rich, clear details, with characteristic light peripheral silver tarnish halo along the mat boundary. The Philander Heslep plate exhibits crisp contrast and bright plate tone with minimal wear. The C.H. Elliott ambrotype shows considerable tarnish. Loose tintypes show minor corner clips and expected light surface abrasions.

Available payment options

  • Visa
  • Mastercard
  • Amex
  • Diners
  • Discover
  • JCB
  • Union Pay

All packages valued at over $250 are shipped with a signature required upon delivery. All packages handled and shipped in-house by Fleischer's Auctions are not insured unless insurance is requested. Successful bidders who would like their packages insured are responsible for notifying us that this is the case and are responsible for paying the cost of insurance.