Fleischer's Auctions
Live Auction

Fall Premier Sale, Day 2: Historic & Early Americana

Fri, Dec 11, 2026 09:00AM EST
  2026-12-11 09:00:00 2026-12-11 09:00:00 America/New_York Fleischer's Auctions Fleischer's Auctions : Fall Premier Sale, Day 2: Historic & Early Americana https://bid.fleischersauctions.com/auctions/fleischers-auctions/fall-premier-sale-day-2-historic-early-americana-22116
Fleischer’s Auctions’ Fall Premier Sale, featuring early and historically significant material relating to American history.
Fleischer's Auctions info@fleischersauctions.com
Lot 3210

[CIVIL WAR & SLAVERY] "An Abolition Traitor" Broadside

Estimate: $1,500 - $3,000
Starting Bid
$250

Bid Increments

Price Bid Increment
$0 $10
$100 $25
$300 $50
$1,000 $100
$2,000 $250
$5,000 $500
$10,000 $1,000
$50,000 $5,000

AN ABOLITION TRAITOR

 

A STRIKING CIVIL WAR BROADSIDE ISSUED IN THE AFTERMATH OF THE NEW YORK DRAFT RIOTS

 

An Abolition Traitor. Letterpress broadside. New York: [Sinclair Tousey], 29 August 1863. Text in a single column. Subscribed in type “A Democratic Workingman.” Visible 10 7/8 x 18 3/8 in., matted and framed to 17 1/8 x 24 5/8 in.

 

RARE. No copy has sold at auction since 1963.

 

An arresting appeal to the working men of New York at a moment when opposition to conscription and emancipation had erupted into violence in the city’s streets. Beneath its accusatory headline, the broadside executes a sharp political reversal: the “abolition traitor” is Robert Toombs, the Georgia slaveholder, former United States senator, and first secretary of state of the Confederacy. His own defense of slavery supplies the evidence against him. By turning Southern arguments about the supposed advantages of enslaved labor against their authors, the writer seeks to persuade Northern laborers that their livelihoods and independence are endangered by the very men leading the rebellion.

 

The date gives the appeal particular force. Scarcely six weeks earlier, New York’s Draft Riots had exposed the depth of the city’s wartime divisions. Anger over compulsory military service, sharpened by the provision allowing a drafted man to pay a $300 commutation fee, combined with racial hostility and fears that emancipation would bring competition for employment. Mobs attacked Black New Yorkers, destroyed property, and burned the Colored Orphan Asylum. Federal troops helped restore order; the draft resumed on August 19, just ten days before the date printed here. The broadside belongs to the urgent effort to recover working-class support for the Union in the aftermath of that catastrophe.

 

At the center of its argument is a passage drawn from Toombs’s defense of slavery delivered at Boston’s Tremont Temple in January 1856. Toombs had suggested that slavery might eventually disappear when population growth depressed wages sufficiently to make the ownership of labor uneconomical. The broadside seizes upon this proposition and presents its implications in deliberately alarming terms: freedom for the enslaved would arrive only when free workers had themselves been reduced to subsistence. “We must make white men and their families as cheap as negro slaves!” the writer declares, before addressing his intended audience directly: “Workingmen! How do you like the prospect held out to you?” An economic justification of slavery becomes, in this reading, an admission of contempt for working people.

 

A second passage, attributed to the Richmond Enquirer, intensifies the attack. The newspaper is quoted describing free society as “a monstrous abortion” and asserting that enslaved people enjoyed better conditions than Northern laborers. Placed before a Northern readership, these claims are made to expose the hostility to free labor beneath Southern professions of paternalism. The author’s concluding accusation is explicit: the Confederacy’s supporters seek to destroy the Union, overturn popular freedom, and reduce white workingmen to the political and social condition of the enslaved.

 

The subscription “A Democratic Workingman” is integral to the persuasion. It presents the appeal as coming from within the constituency it seeks to reach. The text belongs to a series of Unionist broadsides associated with New York publisher Sinclair Tousey, intended to redirect workers’ anger toward slaveholders and their Northern political allies. Its emphasis on white workers’ interests, together with its use of racial prejudice, also reveals the limits of the appeal: opposition to the Confederacy could be urged without demanding a commitment to racial equality. The same broadsides were also issued as pamplets the same year. 

 

The enormous headline gives this closely reasoned political attack an immediate visual authority. Its historical interest lies in the encounter between that public accusation and the intimate concerns of its readers—wages, family support, citizenship, and the fear of dependence. The final question leaves no ambiguity about the response being sought: “Will the Workingmen of the Union help them any longer?”

 

[Civil War, Union, Confederate] [Broadsides, Ephemera, Printing, Posters, Handbills, Documents, Newspapers] [African Americana, African American History, Black History, Slavery, Enslavement, Abolition, Emancipation

Available payment options

  • Visa
  • Mastercard
  • Amex
  • Diners
  • Discover
  • JCB
  • Union Pay

All packages valued at over $250 are shipped with a signature required upon delivery. All packages handled and shipped in-house by Fleischer's Auctions are not insured unless insurance is requested. Successful bidders who would like their packages insured are responsible for notifying us that this is the case and are responsible for paying the cost of insurance.