Fall Premier Sale, Day 2: Historic & Early Americana
Fleischer’s Auctions’ Fall Premier Sale, featuring early and historically significant material relating to American history. Fleischer's Auctions info@fleischersauctions.com
CALL US :
614-305-5120| Price | Bid Increment |
|---|---|
| $0 | $10 |
| $100 | $25 |
| $300 | $50 |
| $1,000 | $100 |
| $2,000 | $250 |
| $5,000 | $500 |
| $10,000 | $1,000 |
| $50,000 | $5,000 |
A FEDERALIST ERA MASTERPIECE OF AMERICAN SWORD CRAFTSMANSHIP, THE DEMONSTRATION PIECE FOR ANDREW JACKSON’S GOLD TENNESSEE PRESENTATION SWORD
One of the finest presentation-grade sabers of the era ever to be publicly offered. In its richness and classical martial imagery, this saber is recognizably an American interpretation of the celebrated Lloyd’s of London Patriotic Fund swords. For an institutional or advanced collection of American swords, it represents a defining acquisition.
In 1819, Nathan Starr approached the State of Tennessee with an offer to undertake a commission of exceptional prestige. The legislature had voted to honor Generals Andrew Jackson and Edmund P. Gaines with “a Sword, with suitable engraving thereon, as a testimonial of the high respect entertained by the State of Tennessee for these public services.” Both men had emerged from the War of 1812 and the subsequent Seminole campaigns as prominent military figures and national heroes. Their swords would be public expressions of gratitude, demanding a standard of workmanship commensurate with the distinction of their recipients. After some debate, Tennessee ultimately committed $1,800 to the pair.
The magnificent saber offered here is believed to have played a formative role in that commission. Its deeply chased hilt and elaborate scabbard ornaments correspond so closely to those of Jackson’s Tennessee presentation sword that it has been proposed as the sample Starr submitted to demonstrate the design and secure the state’s approval. The principal difference is material. Jackson’s hilt and scabbard mounts were executed in solid gold; this saber employs richly gilt brass and a carved ivory grip. In conception, detail, and artistic ambition, however, the relationship is striking.
Two features give this proposed identification particular force. The ricasso bears the explicit acknowledgment “JOHN J. HUB / MOUNTED,” identifying the Philadelphia jeweler and silversmith whose participation in the Jackson sword has long been suspected. Equally revealing are the spaces reserved for a presentation that never took place. A substantial panel at the center of the blade remains uninscribed, while the oval recess on the reverse of the grip, ordinarily intended for a presentation escutcheon, contains a checkered ivory inset. A sword of extraordinary richness was completed, yet no recipient’s name was added. Its apparent purpose as a demonstration of what its makers could achieve offers a persuasive explanation.
Starr was well positioned to pursue such a commission. Working in Middletown, Connecticut, he had already undertaken two important presentation swords: the Congressional sword for Colonel Richard M. Johnson, recognizing his service at the Battle of the Thames, where Tecumseh was killed, and the sword for Commodore Isaac Hull, one of the celebrated naval commanders of the War of 1812. These undertakings established his standing in a demanding field in which the successful manufacturer had to coordinate the work of several highly accomplished specialists.
Although the Jackson sword was supplied under Starr’s name, its artistic execution depended upon craftsmen capable of producing ornament far beyond the requirements of ordinary military arms. For the decoration of his finest blades, Starr is generally believed to have relied upon William John Meer of Philadelphia. Meer was regarded as the foremost American blade etcher of the period from approximately 1815 to 1830, a judgment widely shared by collectors today. The exceptional precision, complexity, and wealth of detail in the etching of this saber strongly suggest his hand.
The maker of the Jackson sword’s hilt and mounts has been more difficult to establish. John J. Hub has long been advanced as the likely craftsman, and his name on the example offered here is consequently of considerable interest. The word “MOUNTED” makes the nature of his contribution unusually clear. Here is a sword whose hilt and scabbard decoration closely parallel the Jackson commission, bearing an express claim by Hub to responsibility for its mounting. While this does not by itself establish his authorship of the Jackson mounts, it provides a potentially important connection between a named Philadelphia artisan and one of the most ambitious American presentation swords of its period.
Hub and Meer are known to have worked together on other prestigious commissions. A particularly instructive example is the presentation sword commissioned by General Edmund Pendleton Gaines for Jonathan Goddard Watmough in recognition of his conduct at Fort Erie in 1814. Assigned a production date of circa 1827 in the account accompanying this saber, and documented as presented in 1830, the Watmough sword brought together several distinguished Philadelphia craftsmen. Harvey Lewis, the noted silversmith, is credited with its artistic design; Rose supplied the blade; Meer executed the etched decoration; and Hub furnished the silver hilt, signed “J HUB.” The sword demonstrates the collaborative arrangements through which such elaborate objects were conceived and completed.
It is therefore plausible that Starr turned to Lewis, Meer, and Hub (or at least to Meer and Hub) for a sample to support his pursuit of the Tennessee contract. The decorative scheme itself drew upon a prestigious precedent. In its richness and classical martial imagery, this saber is recognizably an American interpretation of the celebrated Lloyd’s of London Patriotic Fund swords, presented to Royal Navy officers in grades valued at £30, £50, and £100. The American eagle, the Shield of Columbia, the stars, and the trophies of American arms and flags adapt that established language of honor to the young republic.
A model of this quality would have enabled Tennessee’s representatives to judge the proposed workmanship before authorizing the expense of execution in gold. The state’s $1,800 commitment was substantial. The original assessment of the commission compares $1,800 in 1819 to nearly $50,000 in modern purchasing power on an inflation-only basis, and to slightly more than $2 million when expressed in terms of relative wealth. These comparisons describe the economic scale of the undertaking rather than the present market value of the swords. Such an expenditure would reasonably have warranted careful consideration of the design, materials, and abilities of the craftsmen entrusted with the work.
Starr reportedly claimed that approximately $1,100 of the total budget was consumed by the bullion required for the hilts and mounts alone. After paying the remaining expenses, including the services of artisans of Meer’s and Hub’s standing, he said that his profit amounted to only $20. That figure may be apocryphal, although it need not be far from the truth. The account conveys the financial demands of a commission in which precious materials and painstaking handwork absorbed almost the entire sum available.
Taken together, the resemblance to Jackson’s sword, Hub’s explicit signature, the apparent involvement of Meer, and the absence of a personal dedication form a compelling argument for the saber’s identification as the Tennessee sample. Its actual submission to the state remains an attribution rather than an established documentary fact. Nevertheless, the proposed sequence is persuasive: an elaborate gilt brass model prepared for approval, followed by the production of the two gold swords, with the sample retained to demonstrate the highest grade of work Starr could offer prospective clients.
The oval recess in the grip was most likely intended to receive a silver or gold plate bearing a presentation inscription. Once the Tennessee contract had been obtained and the gold swords were in production, the sample would have continued to serve its purpose without one. The blank blade panel and uninscribed grip are consistent with its having remained a display of the firm’s capabilities throughout much of its working life.
Starr’s saber contracting and production came to an end in the 1830s as the business increasingly concentrated on firearms, continuing under Nathan Starr Jr. What became of this sword during that transition is unknown. However, It survives as an exceptional work of early American arms craftsmanship and as a potentially significant witness to the making of Tennessee’s tributes to Jackson and Gaines. As stated above, for an institutional or advanced collection of American presentation swords, it would be a defining acquisition.
The saber measures 38.5" overall, including its nominally 5.5" hilt. The curved, single-edged, spear-point blade is 33" long and 1.25" wide at the ricasso, with a 24.75" unstopped median fuller. The cast brass hilt is deeply chased and gilt, terminating in an exceptionally detailed eagle-head pommel, the eagle clasping a laurel wreath in its beak. A 5" spread-winged eagle forms the crossguard, which terminates at its upper end in a swirling, forward-swept ball quillon.
The knuckle bow is deeply chased with classical martial themes and incorporates six-pointed star roundels at its center and at its termination against the laurel wreath. The backstrap carries a deeply chased classical topiary motif. The grip is carved ivory, its obverse inlaid with a gilt brass Shield of Columbia surmounted by 15 stars. A checkered oval of ivory is inset at the center of the reverse, occupying the position intended for a presentation escutcheon.
The blade is profusely etched with panels of exceptionally high quality. On the obverse ricasso appears “JOHN J. HUB” over “MOUNTED.” The reverse carries 23" of etching, combining foliate ornament and classical geometric patterns with a central panel depicting a spread-winged eagle above an extensive American panoply of trophies of arms and flags. The obverse is similarly decorated, with the central 7.5" panel deliberately left blank to accommodate an etched presentation.
The accompanying scabbard is of gilt brass of the highest quality, lavishly ornamented with five separately applied, deeply chased gilt brass scenes and two applied and chased gilt brass suspension mounts with rings. The principal scene depicts a cannon surrounded by trophies of arms. Three larger scenes below the lower suspension mount are classical in subject, while the final scene is foliate. The applied decoration displays an exceptional degree of sculptural detail, matching the richness and precision of the hilt.
The mounts are individually secured with blued jewelry screws whose heads were decorated with engraved facets, effectively converting them into permanent pins. This attention to the smallest elements of construction completes an ensemble in which blade, hilt, and scabbard were conceived and executed to a consistently extraordinary standard.
Very Fine. The blade shows some freckles of minor surface oxidation and discoloration that are scattered along its length with the large majority of the original polish and the richly etched decorations remaining intact, although some thinning and minor loss to the etching is noted. The hilt retains the large majority of its gilt finish with some thinning, minor loss and light handling wear. The ivory grip shows a small chip at the upper rear of the obverse, as well as some grain striations. The grip shows some very minor gapping along the backstrap that could be attributed to age shrinkage. The leather throat washer remains intact. The scabbard retains nearly all of its gilt finish with some thinning and fading and the applied decorations remain crisp and very fine. The jewelers screws that secure the mounts show some wear and scattered marks from handling and minor impacts. Really a stunning sword overall and worthy of being a part of a very advanced collection.
Available payment options
All packages valued at over $250 are shipped with a signature required upon delivery. All packages handled and shipped in-house by Fleischer's Auctions are not insured unless insurance is requested. Successful bidders who would like their packages insured are responsible for notifying us that this is the case and are responsible for paying the cost of insurance.
Found in New York circa 1989-1990, ex-Lewis Leigh collection, current private collection.